Student Life
Oxford Union votes to remain in the ECHR
On 22nd October, the Oxford Union rejected the motion ‘The UK Should Withdraw From The ECHR’, with 192 members voting against and 54 in favour.
The motion follows ongoing calls for Britain to leave the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), with the most significant political declaration coming from Conservative Party Leader Kemi Badenoch.
The debate, opened by President Gareth Lim, began with a contentious start. Speakers debating in favour of the motion included Lord Peter Lilley PC, Martin Howe KC, and Suella Braverman KC MP – the latter arguably the biggest draw, given the mass exodus of audience members after Braverman’s concluding argument.
Opposing the motion included George Peretz KC, DPhil Law Candidate Dane Luo, and second-year Philosophy, Politics, and Economics student Sambhav Jain.
Second-year law student Leyton Styles opened the debate with an introduction hinged on his Substack being shared on Tommy Robinson’s social media this summer. Starting on sovereignty, Styles demanded, “Why assume British people are incapable of defending themselves?”. He insisted that most individuals on the opposition already “oppose British empires,” so why “concern [themselves] with legal systems of foreign lands?”. Styles argued that the rights of British people have “been endangered by violent and criminal foreign nationals”.
Jain followed Styles with a cheeky remark that Braverman was seated at the nearest exit because of her record of withdrawals. (This writer can report that Braverman did indeed stick out the whole debate). Jain framed his argument with a metaphor, saying: “We agree that the patient is unwell. Nobody is denying that the UK has a problem at its borders or that the government must act. But the proposition has misdiagnosed the problem.” He left the audience with the reminder that “the test of human rights isn’t what protects the popular but the unpopular, because that can be one of us”.
The debate entered full swing with the proposition’s continuation from Lord Pilley, who told the audience that the “ECHR is 75 years old, the age at which British judges have to retire”. He cautioned that England must leave the ECHR to avoid becoming “like America, with lifetime judicial appointments”, and explained further: “Laws are made by Parliament, accountable to the people and applied impartially by non-political courts. Under the ECHR, laws can be made by the courts accountable to no one and without voters or their elected representatives having a say. This turns the British Constitution on its head [sic]”.
Peterz sparked back, proclaiming that “the [ECHR] is about underpinning democracy and underpinning cooperation with our neighbours.” He emphasised the significance of the courts: “You can’t trust any politicians to hold on to those values.”
Concluding on Britain’s importance to European unity, Peterz urged the audience to remember that “when one European state stops [respecting] human rights, the consequences start affecting everyone else… even those who shove their fingers in their ears for that lesson have to accept that the [ECHR] underpins the cooperation that we need to deal with the array of security threats that we and our continent face”.
After Peterz came Braverman, along with objections to her attendance. Her opening was interrupted by heckler Leo Buckley, who declared, from the balcony, that Reform UK operated as a company rather than a political party.
Braverman’s speech drew an analogy of a failing marriage between the UK and the ECHR, declaring to audiences that “our partner began to control us, coerce us, and frankly, humiliate us”. She said that the UK and ECHR have been in “marriage counselling” for decades, adding that “whenever we say there is a problem… we’re told by Strasbourg that we’re overreacting and getting hysterical. But the reality is, it’s just not working”.
She asserted that rights existed before the creation of Strasbourg, contending rights were provided to women before they were members of the ECHR. “We don’t need a foreign court telling us how to protect civil liberties,” she said, deeming Britain’s ability to self-govern inexplicably required.
As former UK Home Secretary, Braverman pleaded that her political role was restricted because she was “unable” to deport foreign terrorists, paedophiles, drug dealers, and murderers because of their human rights, and that “a nation that cannot control who leaves or enters its territory is not a nation”.
Yet, assuring the audience of her humanity to the struggles facing all individuals, Braverman added: “I’m not here this evening to say that human rights don’t matter. I’m here to say and ask you who should be responsible for defining them and protecting them.”
Luo, next to speak in opposition, listed specific case examples of the necessity of the ECHR, including the court’s eradication of leather-strap discipline, the military ban on gay personnel, and Northern Ireland’s criminalisation of homosexuality. Luo emphasised the ECHR’s strength in protecting the “vulnerable and the voiceless, the little person, against the might and the power of the state”.
Luo also rejected the proposition’s sovereignty argument, saying that “when Parliament has thought that the ECHR has gone too far, it has legislated to limit it”. Luo cited the overseas armed forces legislation and the Rwanda Bill, which Braverman voted against while she was an MP.
Thereafter, Howe provided a legal philosophy from the proposition’s perspective, assessing that the law should be the servant of democracy, not its master, including “our human rights law”. Howe’s call centred on a sense of nationalism and the need for sovereignty, as he urged that “we need to leave the convention in order for the people, our people, to regain democratic control over our laws” and that because Britain is “proud to belong to a country with the longest and deepest history of the protection of fundamental rights and liberties of any country in the world, there is no need for a foreign court to protect national liberties”.
Finally, Bold asked the audience: “Sovereignty, for whom?”. Framing Luo’s reference to the little guy once again, Bold boldly posed an inquiry: “who will uphold the rights of the non-violent protester, who will uphold the rights for the worker whose right to strike is curtailed?”. Asserting the significance of basic freedoms, Bold emphasised her point on the essentiality of the ECHR in a simplistic utterance, “The democratic process is necessary, but not sufficient condition for the protection and vindication of human rights”.
Whether persuasion prominently perfumed the air or audience members left the chambers with the same beliefs before entering, the motion was rejected.
When asked about his perspective, Styles shared his thoughts at the Union’s bar: “Sometimes the numbers in the chamber are skewed by either left-wing activists or students with very overly liberal views. I respect the opinions of all people, and we promote free speech. It is why the Oxford Union is so brilliant, and despite losing the motion, we will not lose the heart of the country. Long live free speech.”
Student Life
Oxford bridges ‘town and gown’ with guide for local students
The University of Oxford has produced a guide to strengthen the link between the academic institution and local schools.
This resource, Opening Oxford, focuses on what the University can give to local communities, and how the University itself can benefit from interacting with the wider region. In the foreword, Vice-Chancellor Irene Tracey described the University’s commitment to “strengthening the University’s links with our local communities” and “ensuring young people across Oxfordshire can see opportunities in the University, whether that is study, employment, or interest in our cultural assets”. She added that universities “thrive when they are part of the life of their region”.
Within the guide, curriculum-linked workshops, enrichment opportunities, and lectures are recommended to realise the University’s vision. The activities featured are available for primary school students through to those navigating higher education and career choices.
It also emphasises helping educators through teacher development opportunities and classroom resources. Specific programmes and resources, such as a two-week research programme at Oxford University Museum of Natural History for sixth-formers and St Anne’s Super-Curricular club which offers online classes, are recommended for those considering applying to universities, including Oxford. It highlights post-school opportunities at the University, such as work experience, careers, and apprenticeships.
This guide contributes to the University’s 2025-2030 Strategic Plan, which outlines how the University will partner with the local community to “sustain excellence in education and research, extend our impact through innovation, and exercise leadership…for the benefit of society”.
The project also builds on the academic outreach that the University has previously developed. Similar to The Oxford College Twinning Project, it attempts to develop a reciprocal relationship between town and gown in the city.
Pro-Vice Chancellor for External Engagement, Sport, and Community, Professor Alex Betts, acknowledges that available initiatives and outreach are “not always visible or transparent to teachers across Oxfordshire”. In his introduction to the guide, he hopes it will help close the educational attainment gap and ensure Oxford is not viewed by young people as “distant and unrelated to their lives”.
The programme’s aim overall is to make the University “relevant and inspiring to all”, not only to its students.
Student Life
Law degree under review after report finds college teaching disparities
Oxford University’s BA Jurisprudence (Law) degree is under faculty review following concerns raised by external examiners and echoed by students, about teaching disparities between colleges.
In a 2026 report seen by Cherwell, both examiners outlined concerns about teaching disparities between Oxford colleges that could affect law students in Final Honour School (FHS) examinations. They questioned whether coordination between colleges was adequate and critiqued a “lack of process” in ensuring students are taught in a “roughly consistent way”.
“There seems to me to be a real possibility of unfairness depending on the topics chosen by the individual tutor in the College and the difficulty of individual questions on the paper,” the report said. One examiner suggested that these issues might not be resolved through simply broadening questions on the paper, while another questioned whether action was needed “to ensure a level playing field across the students in the University”.
Speaking to Cherwell, a final year law student described the situation as “problematic” for students. They said: “The faculty just don’t have enough control over what tutors put on their reading list.”
They told Cherwell that there is no set order for law tutors to teach topics. With the faculty reading list sometimes containing 10-12 weeks of content, this forces some students to teach themselves, especially if the topics not chosen by tutors are easier to score highly on in exams.
They also claimed that in rare instances, some tutors will not include mandatory cases on their reading lists. While these are available to find on the faculty reading list, “it’s on you to make sure you’ve been taught correctly”, according to the student.
Another student claimed that, in last year’s Administrative Law exam, finalists at their college were significantly disadvantaged because they were only taught the first eight weeks of content. They told Cherwell that at colleges where tutors were more versed in administrative law, students were taught more content which was less complex and more likely to come up in exams.
Another law student who graduated in 2025 told Cherwell that they found the tailoring of teaching to exams and the quality of essay feedback varied greatly between colleges.
A University spokesperson told Cherwell: “Undergraduate law teaching combines lectures and classes provided by the Faculty with tutorials arranged by individual colleges. While colleges are responsible for their own tutorial provision, we recognise the importance of ensuring that students are appropriately prepared for their examinations, regardless of their college.”
Cherwell understands that the Faculty of Law is currently reviewing the course and its teaching provision in a working group.
Student Life
Oxford semiconductor research leads to breakthrough in solar energy
A collaboration between scientists at the University of Oxford and Wuhan University has made a major breakthrough in solar energy efficiency.
Researchers found that bismuth sulphide can absorb light strongly without losing the electrical charge it produces, making it a promising material for semiconductors, the part of a solar cell which converts sunlight into energy.
When a semiconductor absorbs sunlight, it uses its energy to free electrons and leaves tiny, positively charged ‘holes’ in their place. To produce electricity, these positive and negative charges must be rapidly harvested before they meet and cancel each other out. However, laws of physics state that a good absorber of light must also be a good emitter, and therefore the semiconductors that absorb light most strongly are also the ones that lose their charges most quickly.
Solar energy research has long been slowed by the difficulty of finding materials that balance semiconductor absorbency and efficiency.
The discovery of bismuth sulphide, published in Nature in October, unlocks a solution. The researchers discovered it has a rare quantum arrangement that allows it to absorb light efficiently while also making it harder for excited electrons and holes to recombine.
Solar energy constitutes only 6% of Britain’s electricity. Primarily because of Chinese investment, 91% of new global solar and wind facilities are cheaper than the cheapest available fossil-fuel power. However, weather, grid infrastructure, and technological limitations have created a firm ceiling on the UK’s solar energy harvesting. This comes as Prime Minister Andy Burnham has announced the launch of a new government body to invest in the national electricity grid, as concerns mount over the durability and capacity of the UK’s energy infrastructure.
The government projects that the solar sector will support 35,000 jobs by 2030. This includes roles within the solar technology company Oxford Photovoltaics, which contributed to the study. The company was founded in 2010 as a spin-out from the University and now claims to be “commercialising the world’s most efficient solar technology to power the next generation of clean energy”.
Solar energy is also expected to play a major role in the government’s plans for an Oxford-Cambridge ‘growth corridor’. A recent report suggests the UK’s premier innovation zone is falling behind its global rivals, as China continues to build as much as 74% of all solar and wind projects worldwide.
This discovery of the bismuth sulphide semiconductor may trigger changes in the renewable energy sector. To do so, however, requires rapid commercial implementation of the technology. Researchers have yet to establish whether the increased energy savings of bismuth sulphide are enough for it to turn a profit.
-
Oxford united FC4 weeks agoOxford United beat Wigan Athletic 2-1 in League One victory
-
Oxford united FC4 weeks agoRamsey on Oxford United’s Arsenal-inspired set-piece threat
-
Oxford united FC4 weeks agoLeicester City hit with same transfer embargo as Oxford United
-
Traffic & Transport4 weeks agoAndy Burnham launches campaign against ‘headphone dodgers’ on public transport | Transport policy
-
Student Life3 weeks ago“I am proud of being a Jew, and equally proud of being an Arab”: Professor Avi Shlaim on Iraq, Zionism and belonging
-
Student Life4 weeks agoI no longer want to be an astronaut
-
Student Life3 weeks agoThe Vinted paradox: Consuming our way out of overconsumption
-
Property & Housing4 weeks agoOxfordshire’s Equinox 2035 strategy launched at House of Commons
