Connect with us

Traffic & Transport

‘I felt my spine and body split’: the woman who was hit by a child on a Lime bike – and denied compensation | Ebikes

Published

on


As Jane Ouartsi walked across a pedestrianised square in central London, on a Friday evening in early August three years ago, she linked arms with her partner, Dave Mathias, and told him how much she had enjoyed the afternoon they had spent together, eating pizza in Soho and visiting an art installation. It was the last time she can remember feeling properly happy and relaxed.

“We were walking quite slowly, talking about the art. It’s hard to remember exactly, but I think I was saying what a lovely lunch, and then all of a sudden there was a horrific impact,” she says. “I felt my spine and body split and I thought my life was over.”

Ouartsi, who is in her late 60s, can’t bear to watch the CCTV recording of the Lime bike accident that left her with such severe injuries that she spent a total of 36 days in hospital and 18 months learning how to walk again. Mathias flinches each time he sees it, tracking the progress from the left of the screen to the right of a young rider, possibly around 10 years old, as he speeds across the empty square and knocks Ouartsi over. He has had to study it repeatedly over the past three years as he has tried, and failed, to persuade staff at the bike rental company Lime to acknowledge the life-changing consequences of the incident.

CCTV footage of Jane Ouartsi’s Lime bike accident

Last week, the clip of the collision went viral as it emerged that the company has not paid compensation to the couple and has not responded to their calls for more to be done to stop rogue underage cyclists using the electric bikes illegally, flouting all traffic rules, cycling on pavements and jumping red lights.

“It has become like the wild west,” Ouartsi says, sitting on a pile of cushions in her west London flat, arranged for maximum comfort in the face of continuing stiffness and pain caused by the incident. She suffered a fractured collar bone, two spinal fractures and a badly broken femur that required three operations to fix. She says the medical staff at the central London hospital where she was treated had not previously seen such severe injuries, but were becoming used to treating patients with ebike-related damage. “They said it was happening more every week, that it was a drain on their time, fixing people’s arms and legs when they could be doing other work.”

The footage has attracted attention because it chimes with the ambivalence provoked by the rising presence of Lime bikes in the capital. Although there is warmth for the arrival of alternatives to cars, there is also unease that some of the bikes are ridden and parked irresponsibly.

‘I thought my life was over’ … Ouartsi after the accident. Photograph: Supplied image

Ouartsi, a retired Marks & Spencer shop worker, says she has become a different person since being hit. When she was discharged from hospital, ambulance staff had to carry her up to her first-floor flat and, for a year, she was unable to walk upstairs to her bedroom or to the bathroom – she had to have a single bed and a commode installed in the sitting room. “I almost forgot what it looked like upstairs,” she says. She spent weeks practising walking up steps, and Mathias, a joiner, had to take an extended period off work to help her recover, installing grab handles around the flat so she was able to manoeuvre herself into a standing position. It took months before she felt confident enough to take a bus, she still relies on a walking stick and the couple, who loved travelling to Scotland, do not envisage making the journey again.

“I’m made up of nuts and bolts and screws. I had to learn to walk again like a baby,” Ouartsi says, as Mathias pulls out an A4 file of X-ray photographs revealing different attempts by doctors to mend the complicated break in her femur. The titanium inserted into her leg buckled and failed, so it needed to be replaced. “I’m very scared of falling. I don’t want to go back to hospital again. It has been a horrendous time.”

Ouartsi wants the company to rethink the weight and the speed of the bicycles and impose stiff penalties on people who cycle irresponsibly. “I honestly don’t know how I survived. I was a broken china doll – it’s amazing how the doctors put me back together.”

‘I’m made up of nuts and bolts and screws’ … Ouartsi in hospital. Photograph: Supplied image

In the abstract, Ouartsi and Mathias support the idea that cities should have more bicycles and fewer cars. A few years ago, Ouartsi enjoyed hiring Santander Cycles, which are not electric, and cycling around the perimeter of Hyde Park with her grandson. But their experience has hardened a sense that Lime and the owners of other ebikes need to take more decisive action to promote the safety of pedestrians and riders. They support the principle of making life easier for cyclists, but not at the expense of people who prefer to walk.

“People need to use them sensibly, on the road. I’d also rather they weren’t electric so that people could get more exercise,” says Mathias. “People zoom on the pavements because it’s dangerous on the roads,” Ouartsi adds.

Mathias still doesn’t understand why Lime has not done more to prevent children from riding ebikes. In the seconds after the impact, he shouted at the child, who went to sit by himself on a bench nearby and cried. He tried to take a photograph of the boy, but was prevented by a woman, who he thinks was the boy’s mother, who arrived some time later. When the paramedics were transferring Ouartsi into an ambulance, they disappeared before police were able to speak to them or take down their names.

“Neither of us want to prosecute a 10-year-old or his mother, but we needed a name on the form to claim on Lime’s insurance,” says Mathias. Without a name, securing any payment of damages has proved complex. The police closed the case, and an attempt to work on a no win, no fee basis with solicitors ended because, the lawyer said in an email to Mathias, the rider had not been identified, so it was not possible to make a claim.

In October 2024, Mathias was at a well-attended meeting in Kensington town hall, where representatives from Lime, and other ebike firms such as Forest, were there to listen to residents’ complaints about the rising number of poorly parked hire bikes. Charities representing blind residents and people with limited mobility have detailed how difficult chaotic parking has made navigating parts of London with looser regulations about returning ebikes. Mathias took the opportunity to tell Lime publicly about his partner’s injuries. “Mostly they were elderly people there complaining about the bikes being strewn all over the pavement,” he says. “When I got up and said my piece, people gasped.” Two Lime representatives came to speak to him afterwards and offered to help.

‘I had to learn to walk again like a baby.’ Photograph: Supplied image

“We were really sorry to hear of your experience and we want to do everything we can to support you,” a senior public affairs manager emailed him the next day. Another email from Lime promises: “We are dedicated to ensuring that your concerns are properly addressed.” But somehow, this help has not materialised. A message sent via the Lime Claims Management System in January of this year offers “deepest regrets regarding what your wife Jane and yourself have been through as a result of this incident” but states that the firm has again reviewed its records and been unable to find details of who rented the bike or the identity of the rider.

“This vehicle was not being used as part of an active ride. As the rider was using the vehicle illegally, we have no record of the trip having occurred and no information on the rider,” the message notes. “Without any further details regarding the user’s identification we are unable to provide any further support on the incident at this time.” At one point, Lime told Mathias that they were willing to make a financial gesture, with no admission of liability, but this offer has not materialised.

Robert Goodsell also experienced difficulties securing compensation for his wife, Helen, 79, after she was struck by an underage rider, also riding on the pavement, as she stepped out from her front garden on to the street in north London in 2024. The video of the collision, filmed from their doorbell camera, gives a sense of the speed of the impact.

Her injuries were minor, but she still feels stressed when she sees Lime bikes on the road. When Robert tried to make an insurance claim on her behalf, he discovered that Lime’s insurers were unable to settle because the rider was underage, which was an exclusion under the terms of the insurance policy. Lime later offered a modest ex-gratia payment, without admission of liability.

He suggested that safety rules should be stencilled on to the bikes, setting out that bicycles must not be ridden on pavements and riders should not go through red lights, but although Lime expressed polite interest in the idea, it was not implemented.

‘People gasped’ … Ouartsi and partner, Dave Mathias, who has spent three years trying to persuade Lime to acknowledge the life-changing consequences of the incident. Photograph: Graeme Robertson/The Guardian

“The challenges I would like to put to Lime are: why do they refuse to put basic safe riding guidance and rules visibly on their bikes? Why do they not visibly number their bikes so that the public can report bad behaviour?” he says. He also believes it would be helpful if the company was able to limit the bicycle’s speed in pedestrian areas.

The solicitor Sam Collard, the head of cycling accident claims at Osbornes law, says that for the past 18 months his firm has been receiving about 10 inquiries a month, with the vast majority involving Lime bikes, although there were also people wishing to claim damages against other ebike providers. Claims are divided between pedestrians hurt by cyclists, riders who have been injured by defective bikes while cycling and riders with fractures caused by the sheer weight of the bicycle falling on them, a phenomenon known as “Lime bike leg”. “It ranges from cuts and scrapes to more serious issues – brain injury, fractured skull. We’re in the process of settling a number of cases, with payments of between £20,000 and £100,000.”

Collard acknowledged it was more complicated to receive an insurance payout when the identity of the rider was unknown. “But certainly, morally, they have questions to answer about how a 10-year-old came to be riding their bike,” he says.

Doorbell footage of Helen Goodsell being struck by an underage rider

A private briefing prepared for Transport for London’s safety panel, and seen by the Evening Standard, showed that hire bikes, such as the battery-powered cycles provided by Lime, Forest and Voi, accounted for 32% of cyclist v pedestrian crashes attended by police in the capital in 2024, up from 3% in 2017. TfL figures also show that there was an 8% rise in serious injuries to people cycling in 2024 (the last period for which records are available), but notes that this increase is heavily outweighed by the 39% increase in cycling journeys recorded since a 2010-14 baseline, suggesting serious injury per cycle journey has reduced.

A spokesperson for Lime said: “Our thoughts are with Jane and her family, and we are sorry for the distress this incident has caused. We take incidents like this extremely seriously. This situation has been carefully reviewed and handled in line with our policies. We are also sorry to hear about Helen’s incident. Safety informs everything we do – from how we design and maintain our vehicles, to our rider education, and how we work with cities.”

The firm said the bike involved in Ouartsi’s accident was stolen and ridden illegally, not rented, and added that more than 99.99% of Lime trips in London last year ended without a reported incident. Lime launched a redesigned, smaller rental ebike, with batteries repositioned towards the back of the vehicle, earlier this year, rolling out 1,500 new cycles, in addition to the fleet of up to 50,000 dockless ebikes it already operates in the capital.

Lime fines riders who end their journeys in unauthorised places, with fines ranging between £2 and £20 and repeat offenders can be banned. The firm slows bikes down when they enter “go slow” areas, such as Regent’s Park or Hyde Park in London.

Mathias wants to be positive about these improvements, but is frustrated that the significant impact of the accident on their lives has not been recognised.

“The psychological impact of what happened is far reaching,” he says. “Jane and I had hopes and dreams for retirement and our future together which have been blighted.”

Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here



Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Traffic & Transport

Uber driver takes TfL to court over ‘pain‘ caused by licence renewal delay | TfL

Published

on


An Uber driver who got into thousands of pounds of debt and feared losing his home due to delays in Transport for London renewing his licence to pick up passengers is taking on the organisation in the high court in the first challenge of its kind.

Julius Mugabo, 55, has been an Uber driver licensed by TfL since 2016. Under the Private Hire Vehicles (London) Act 1998, all minicab drivers cannot work lawfully unless TfL has carried out checks on them and issued or renewed their licences. These licences must be renewed every three years.

There are approximately 100,000 private hire drivers in London working through apps such as Uber and Bolt. According to freedom of information data obtained by the Conservatives, almost 18,000 of them have received “goodwill” payments of between £300 and £500 due to delays in renewing their licences.

“Because of all the pain I have been through, I am bringing this legal challenge to help other drivers,” Mugabo told the Guardian.

Julius Mugabo, who has launched a landmark case against Transport for London. Photograph: Supplied

Mugabo had not experienced any problems until he made a routine renewal application at the end of last year. TfL repeatedly delayed processing his renewal application, asking him to provide supporting documentation he said he had already provided.

“Even if TfL delay renewing licences, drivers like me still have to eat and pay bills. My licence expired at the end of March 2026. I only received my renewed licence recently after I started the legal action against TfL,” he said.

“Because of their delays everything in my life was a mess. I owed HMRC £3,000 in tax but because I couldn’t pay my tax bill on time the bill has gone up to £20,000 because of the interest. We didn’t lose our home but I was under so much stress and pressure. The landlord threatened to evict us because I struggled to pay the rent.”

The high court action against TfL alleges that the transport authority breached its legal duties by failing to process private hire vehicle licence renewals on time.

In a ruling granting a full judicial review hearing, Mr Justice Sweeting said the delay “caused immediate and serious consequences for [Mugabo] and his family”.

He added: “TfL accepts that the processing of the claimant’s application did not meet its usual standards.”

The Independent Workers’ Union of Great Britain (IWGB), which represents private hire drivers on apps such as Uber and Bolt, said it had many members affected by the TfL licence processing delays, and that some of drivers had fallen into debt, had lost their cars and faced eviction. It is supporting the high court challenge.

Alex Marshall, the president of the IWGB, said: “As they celebrate this ruling bringing them closer to justice, the minicab drivers who keep London moving are sending TfL a clear message: they will not be taken for a ride.

“The suffering TfL inflicted on its predominantly migrant private hire driver workforce speaks volumes about who this public institution values, and who it takes for granted. TfL could easily have acted at the earliest sign of crisis, as the first drivers lost their incomes through no fault of their own. Instead, it watched at least 17,000 others suffer the same fate.

“By the time TfL finally acted, drivers had burned through their savings, lost their houses and fallen into debts they are still working longer hours to repay. Now, thanks to drivers’ tireless fighting and campaigning, TfL will have to answer for its failures in court. We will not stop until TfL has been forced to fix this broken system for good.”

Ahmed Aydeed, of Deighton Pierce Glynn solicitors, who is representing Mugabo, said: “TfL regularly strips drivers of their livelihoods, by failing to provide renewal licences before the expiry of the previous licence. Any driver who continues to work while waiting for their renewal licence is liable for criminal prosecution.

“No one should be stripped of their ability to feed their families and pay their bills, especially during this cost of living crisis. Any public authority that does this to working-class people is not fit for purpose,” he said.

A TfL spokesperson said: “We are aware of the judicial review claim, which has been brought by one driver regarding the processing of his licence. We are awaiting the date of the hearing.”



Source link

Continue Reading

Traffic & Transport

Making the British countryside more accessible and inviting to all | Walking

Published

on


What a joy to read John Harris’s piece on the cultural changes taking place in rural areas (Walking the Peak District, I discovered a wonderful rejection of the right’s monotone vision of England, 23 August. My husband and I have walked many miles in the Peak District and we would comment on the monocultural nature of other walkers. As a headteacher, I also took groups of children to stay in Hartington Hall, where Harris stayed with his own children, and other school groups also appeared to be monocultural. We knew nothing about Black Girls Hike or Steppers UK that Harris mentions, but hope that these movements will support positive change.
Nina Young
Collingham, Nottinghamshire

John Harris rightly highlights the cost of gastropubs and boutique Airbnbs replacing budget alternatives as an issue, but overlooked another. The replacement of basic (cheap) campsites with (expensive) glamping yurts and fully serviced campervan pitches is threatening dirt-cheap summer holidays spent backpacking around the country and learning to appreciate new landscapes and peoples, from which many of us oldies benefited greatly.
Mike Coogan
Abbeystead, Lancashire

John Harris omits one critical issue that impacts participation. Public transport outside cities and towns is often poor. To places like Bellever on Dartmoor, the location of one of his favourite hostels, buses are very limited indeed.
Les Bright
Exeter

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.



Source link

Continue Reading

Traffic & Transport

‘Without us, no wheel would turn’: the unsung heroes keeping England’s transport moving | Business

Published

on


Not many people get to park their car here – bang in the middle of Heathrow airport, on the taxiway just a stretch of grass away from where a line of passenger planes is coming in to land.

It’s close enough to see the shimmering air and smoke as nose tyres hit the tarmac. “An A380 will put down as much rubber as a car’s entire tyre,” Jack Quantick-Thorne says. He knows – part of his job is to ensure the runway team scrapes it off and patches things up overnight. And it is all recycled, he adds.

The airfield operations officer is not in the limelight much, but is one of a host of unsung workers keeping transport moving. And some jobs far from the public eye turn out to be not only essential, but surprisingly challenging.

Jack Quantick-Thorne, airfield operations officer, Heathrow

Passengers might only catch a glimpse of Quantick-Thorne from a window seat on landing, if he grabs the paddles to marshal a plane into the exact designated spot at the stand. “People just think you’re that person with the table tennis bats,” he grimaces slightly, as the Guardian requests a demonstration. “That’s like 5% of my job.”

In fact, most planes are now brought to the stand via laser-guided electronic displays. But human marshalling remains a crucial backup. Brandishing the paddles, Quantick-Thorne beckons in a taxiing British Airways arrival, the pilot peering down from the cockpit and steering 50 tonnes of plane straight towards him. The nosewheel travels bang on the guideline, stopping exactly in position for the airbridge to swing in and allow passengers to disembark.

Nerve-racking? “No. When you’ve got a really big plane, an A380, you need a second marshal right by the wheel to check it’s stopped in the right place,” he says.

Back in the car, the job continues: “I’m patrolling, I’m looking around, scanning everything – is the refueller doing his job properly, has the aircraft got chocks under its wheels?”

That includes monitoring the road system under Heathrow’s airfields, recognising every vehicle and checking any infringement: drivers here can also clock up points on their licence, if he spots them.

Officers also need to look out for wildlife – particularly birds, a serious danger for jet planes (and vice versa). How does he deal with them? We’ve got methods of dispersal,” says the airfield operations officer.

These, marvellously, turn out to be speakers on the roof of the van, which play a range of bird sounds: “If I saw a flock of starlings, if I played a starling noise, the starling would think, ‘Oh, maybe there’s a predator nearby,’ and they fly off.”

And, he demonstrates, “I’ve got common gull. Black-headed gull. I’ve got a falcon”.

Are there falcons? “No,” he explains patiently. “So you think about it from a bird’s point of view. If there’s a pigeon over there, best play a falcon so it will fly off.”

Jack Quantick-Thorne at work. Last year he had to tow the Concorde that still stands at the edge of the airfield across for an exhibition. Photograph: Graeme Robertson/The Guardian

If he now knows birds, it’s the planes that drew him here. He was previously at Nats, the air traffic control centre in Swanwick, managing the planes, but never up close. There is more to it than the paddles – but, he confesses, he takes every opportunity to use them, and records each plane that he has marshalled, including every aircraft in BA’s short-haul fleet.

Being a pilot is the dream, he admits, but the prohibitive training costs – £100,000 or more – put it out of reach. For an enthusiast, he reckons the job is the next best thing. Last year he had to tow the Concorde that still stands at the edge of the airfield across for an exhibition: “It was the first time one had moved in years – incredible to see in the rear-view mirror.”

Chris Thackaberry, network traffic controller, Transport for London

The day starts in Victoria Station House overlooking the bus terminus, a grand old building that looks considerably less so inside, where Chris’s desk is surrounded by hundreds of cardboard diversion signs.

About 500 of the capital’s 19,000 bus stops are on his patch in Westminster – home to some of Britain’s most congested streets, where dozens of bus routes cross. Roadworks are the bane of the bus and Thackaberry’s job is to keep them moving – armed with a van, pliers and zip ties.

Sometimes he can plan for roadworks months ahead. But other days are less predictable, when life suddenly blocks a route: “It could be a broken-down vehicle or a burst water main, but I’ve had windows falling out of buildings, I’ve had a collapsed horse on a bridge. I had an upside down Lamborghini in Piccadilly … I don’t know if it was sticking to the 20mph limit.”

Christopher Thackaberry, a network traffic controller with TfL, in his van. Photograph: Linda Nylind/The Guardian

His incident response van contains an orderly standing desk area and even a printer to rustle up more signs if needed, as well as spill dry sacks, ready to suck up any diesel or oil leaked over the road.

It also has two cylinders affixed to the wall containing “spit kits” – swabs to pick up any saliva aimed at staff, with clear bags to seal, ready to take the evidence to the police. “It’s just part and parcel of when you’re working in London, for anyone in uniform.”

In a sweltering Trafalgar Square, as he hunts in the midst of four lanes of traffic to hitch his cardboard signs to any available piece of spare street furniture, the complexity of the puzzle becomes clearer.

“There’s so many routes go through here, we’re fighting with ourselves for space.”

skip past newsletter promotion


Sarah, railway signaller, York

Gone are most of the signal boxes of old: these days, Britain’s railway is mostly controlled from one of 12 remote centres. From a windowless room in York, trains right down the East Coast mainline are guided on their way.

“In the old days, it was lever pulling,” says Sarah. “Now it’s a click of the mouse instead. Like a computer game scenario, but it’s real track, real trains, real people. We have to manually click, signal to signal, for every train that comes through our patch.”

Signallers have five screens at eye level showing the railway, and five above with timetables and traffic management information.

“When you first start the job, it feels so far removed. There’s no windows, it’s like a black hole in the middle of the building, but you are signalling trains from York all the way into King’s Cross. I remember thinking: ‘How many hundreds of people are on that train we’re signalling?’”

Anything from a circuit failure to a trespasser to a sick passenger on a train can hold up the lines. “Our job initially in any incident is to make the area safe – that’s first and foremost. And then we look for a workaround, to keep trains moving. The days when there are serious incidents are few and far between. But every day there’s something.”

Jamie *, public service vehicle engineer, Manchester

At Jamie’s bus depot, servicing the Bee Network, the first shift starts at 5am and the last ends at 1am, but engineers might stay through the night with a breakdown.

“In the daytime it’s routine: vehicles are inspected by law on a monthly basis,” he says. “But engineers have bus driving licences too, if a bus was to break down, often we’d take another one out to the driver to keep the service running.”

With city buses that stop and start frequently, there is typically more treatment and maintenance. And newer vehicles don’t necessarily mean less work, he says: “They bring a lot of new issues and we’re constantly learning, going back to college on courses to learn the tech.

“Electric buses haven’t made the job easier – but they and the new diesel engines are clean. Working back in the day, it was a hell of a lot dirtier, especially in depots indoors or undercover,” says the vehicle engineer.

He will check each bus’s brakes, emissions tests and inspect the nuts and bolts everywhere from the underside to the driver’s cab. “We see a lot in the press about the conditions in the cab, but we’re cleaning those buses: it’s like a greenhouse, and the heat from the engines also comes into our workshop.

“Even the drivers don’t understand what engineers do – I always say we are the forgotten people. But without us, no wheel would turn.”

Frankie *, baggage handler, Gatwick

The thing people don’t understand, explains Frankie, is that the placement of bags in the hold is not random. “It’s all done on weight distribution. You have to put baggage where you’re told – it is a very specific job, you do not deviate.”

At many airports, larger aircraft such as long-haul planes are loaded with bags already in large crates, lifted into position by machine. But short-haul flights at Gatwick are loaded manually. “An average bag is about 20kg and the average load is 90 bags off, 90 on, for three or four people. If you do eight turns a day, that’s nearly 30 tonnes your team is lifting. You get fitter – it’s like going to the gym, you end up lifting heavier and heavier bags.”

Passengers who fear for their luggage often make the job harder: “The worst thing is shrink-wrapped bags. It’s slippery, harder to hold on to, and less grip for the belt to pull up. And those straps around bags, they can get jammed in the belts and break them.

“People don’t realise how damaging it can be – and pointless. If you’re on a flight where customs do spot checks, they go for the bags that are wrapped. And there is so much CCTV and security. If I get caught opening a bag, I’d lose my job – why would I risk that?”

There are, says Frankie, more women doing the job now: “It’s getting more female-friendly. A lot of people choose this type of job to get into aviation: they want to be pilots or crew eventually, and just want to be around planes any way they can.”

* Names have been changed



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending